INTRODUCING A NEW SUBJECT TO AN OLD TRADITION
THE SPRING IS FINALLY IN HERE
It's muggy. The humidity has rendered the air around me completely sticky still. I can imagine the pollen stuck to my beard, the bees nesting inside my pits. My nasal passages are clogged with a remarkable sensitivity. I am trying to stay as still as possible, my shitty fan blowing left and right. We are both rehearsing wind. Outside my window people chat, they drink and they laugh. And inside my heat, I writhe. The veins in my hands are so swollen I can hear them. The skin on my body pricks with anxiety. Yet the music festival outside proceeds. There are beats and cheers, crowds and crowds of laughter and fun. I can’t join them, they are on that side of the wall. I can’t ignore them, it’s too hot to close the windows. I sit and vibrate in a closed anger and humiliation. Across the seas a Gala sparkles with gowns and exuberance. I heard some cunt even meowed into the mic. I am not afforded such lofty creative expression, I am not afforded the ego trip of feeling a sense of importance through the institutionalised capitalist mode of acceptance. I am poor and I am still, and I can hear cheers outside of my window. I remember when I wasn’t so angry. When I could run around in autumn with my friends. I can remember the ball we kicked and the jets we ignored. We were kids. We still are. And I am realising for the first time that I didn't know what it meant to be alive, that my trauma was normalised into an acceptance of being. That being was substituted for by rehearsed hope. My shitty fan blows left and right. I will probably get killed soon. And hopefully my family does too. I don’t want my father picking up my dangling head from a torn up building floor. He doesn’t deserve that. I remember once he made us lunch which was also breakfast and dinner and we made fun of him because it was so terrible. My mother had been missing. He didn't want to tell us but we knew. That was two weeks ago but feels like longer. I'm sure it'll be fine. My allergies are just acting up. The spring in Rafah this year is particularly violent.
13.5.24

THEY FLEW, NOT SAVAGELY BUT PERSISTENTLY
THE LIGHT SPLIT THEM LIKE LEMONS IN SUMMER
I USED TO RESPECT
Jerry Saltz and Jerry Gogosian. I used to respect the art critics who spoke their minds, who thumbed our faces at the hyperbolic arrogance of the institutionalised and over-produced, over-fetishised Classist Arts Scene. I used to respect their daring stance. They were the voice of the people, the representatives of 99.99% of the arts crowd who were fed up with how the Arts World made millions off the backs of the starving. But no longer. Saltz, in his privileged narrow mindedness afforded to most upper Middle Class Democratic Boomers, is so consumed with vilifying Donald Trump and the Reds (the Red Pill whores, the gung-ho Republicans) that he has lost his humanity to the allegiance of his Blue party’s sovereignty and power. Jerry Saltz is superficially for the artist, but to the core he is a paid-for American Democrat who is loyal to one colour while convincing us to examine and consider the whole wheel. Gogosian, in her self-cultivated online following, achieved through years of respected, independent hard work and valid criticism of the Art World, is now a servant of the Art Intelligencia. Her un-bought-for criticism is a front for her classist view that she's purely about one thing: Art and Art only. Though this may seem like a noble stance, which it often is, in this current global climate where her country has been actively funding a live genocide for the last eight months is in fact an act of Ignorance (of the world’s deafening protest) and Avoidance (of taking any stance at all). She is feigning an underdog narrative while ignoring the massacring of children in Gaza; she wants both the street cred of speaking the truth no one dares while simultaneously ignoring the public’s discontent, repulsion and protest.
What is Art? It is beautiful and lofty, it is the expression of something greater, the pursuit of that plane between Man and God. But ultimately Art is of man, the Gods are a potential ideal. And therefore Art is unavoidably and inherently Politicised. The act of not politicising Art is the act of denying, ignoring your own humanity, of avoiding your surroundings, the problems and fears and trends, the systemic manipulation of the grid with which you are surrounded. Jerry Gogosian refuses to address any part of Gaza while simultaneously convincing us that she should have been invited (tongue firmly placed in cheek!) to the tone deaf and extravagant MET Gala. Not once addressing the perversion of both the Classist and Systemic corruption of the Gala’s blatant and hypocritical ignorance. Both Jerries are charlatans and the products of Liberal Capitalist societies which praise their independence in the name of ‘free speech’ yet inevitably pull them into the Establishment’s stay-in-your-lane order. You can choose your crayons sweetie but you better colour inside the lines! If John Berger and Susan Sontag were alive today they would be live tweeting about Rafah, they would be writing essays calling the Art World’s silence into question, calling America’s, and therefore the Art World’s, complicity in mass murder, and ultimately discrediting such weak-souled wannabe renegades as frauds and lackeys who only serve to legitimise the Establishment’s superficial projection of Independence while conforming to the Empire’s Capitalistic norms. Berger and Sontag would not give in to their grids, they would not shut their eyes and close their ears to Gaza, regardless of political alignment or monetary threat. Art is not about money, as both Jerries would attest to, but the principle, the pursuit, the truth of Mankind. Berger and Sontag’s Humanity would attempt to lift Gaza up as high as they possibly could, to use their platforms for the betterment of Man in the name of the Arts. But not the Jerries, they ignore Man, settling instead for banal bipartisan melodrama and the projection of an independent voice which only serves to masturbate the upper middle class into thinking they are in with the cool crowd, virtue signalling that yes, they are for the people! while diminishing and ignoring them altogether.
“Capitalism survives by forcing the majority, whom it exploits, to define their interests as narrowly as possible.This was once achieved by extensive deprivation. Today in the developed countries it is being achieved by imposing a false standard of what is and is not desirable.”
- John Berger, Ways of Seeing
Jerry Salts and Jerry Gogosian should be ashamed of themselves. I hope they can find forgiveness in the rising number of their followers and their bank accounts. And not in their Gods.

🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
🇮🇱
Me and my Sisters, Sitting around a Table with Yugoslavian Adults
I can’t read Twitter entries anymore.
I can’t read such shallow politics, the kind we as children avoided from our elders because even then they seemed shallow and narrow minded, ultimately hopeless.
Stuck. There was no point to even try.
This was our world view passed down from the table our mother set.
There is no point in un-sticking someone from their Nationalism, it simply wouldn't work. If it failed to work after a bloody civil war, it certainly wouldn’t now. They had dug themselves into a grave.
As children we understood that that's just how Man's condition went.
Some are and some are not.
Our father smoked until he got a heart attack and almost died.
Then he stopped for good.
But these people, they are still smoking, they are still drunk on national propaganda and pride.
It’s worse than cigarettes. It's an ailment until death.
It’s best to nod along and leave a person like that to their God. Reason is beyond.
Here is a coffee, some sugar. Look at how our mother taught us good manners.

ANALYSIS OF CONTEMPORARY SERBO-BOSNIAN RAP SEQUENCES
2 of 2
Danza's seven bars from his song featuring Venok - TENZIJE (TENSIONS)
Glamur je fikcija jebla te kamera
Šljunak ispred kuće kuća bez maltera
Neka polako daj da se zapjeva
Rupe od metaka - Dejton estetika
Ožiljci geler prostetika, jebiga
Ni nama se sve to ne sviđa
Pitaš me kako je, ne pitaj
The glamour is fiction, fuck your camera
Gravel in front of the house, the house with no mortar¹
Let it slowly be sung²
bulletholes, Dayton aesthetic³
scars from the shrapnel prosthetics, fuck it
we don’t like all of this either
you ask me how it’s going, don’t ask⁴
This translation is designed to be read line for line and will appear clunky, that is done in the effort to analyse each line independently rather than abide to time signatures, rhythms or rhyme in the respective English translation.
¹Gravel in front of the house, the house with no mortar. After the war, many homes were left either destroyed or half destroyed. A recurring aesthetic phenomenon of many villages across Bosnia (and ex-Yugoslvia) are half finished houses; the gravel in front of a home, the home with bricks and no mortar to hold them together. These homes typically have a foundation set but the first or second floors are made up of stacked bricks not being held together by anything. They are inhabitable past the ground floor. Due to this, the homes in villages where the war was very prevalent often posses similar aesthetics: paint-less with tonal colours that bricks, cement, plaster, mortars, gravel and similar typical building materials posses. This is the outcome of living architecture in the process of rebuilding after the war. Even though some live in them now, for the most part the houses are unfinished.
the preceding line The glamour is fiction, fuck your camera is a direct criticism/reference of the following Gravel in front of the house, the house with no mortar: The families that have returned to live in their houses share photos online or in social circles of their new lives. The artist here implies that this is simply a projected glamour because the reality (the mentioned homes) is far more dire and hopeless than Instagram would have you believe.
However in the following line ²Let it be sung he absolves all actions of people posing for glamour against the bland reality of half-finished homes. A more literal translation of the line could be It’s ok to slowly allow (oneself) to sing. This is a typical phrase in the Balkans that would mean something like Let it be, what’s done is done. This harkens back to a different time. The Balkan culture, steeped in hundreds of years of oppressive Ottoman rule, is rich in song and poetry from the years where collective attitudes, whether jovial, sombre or dramatic, had an element of We keep singing and going on with the oppressive conditions. The what’re you gonna do? sentiment is something that is historically ingrained for us, meaning both; we do what we can against the forces and we do what we can against the forces whilst accepting/succumbing to their overwhelming powers.
It is both: Acknowledging the hope and acknowledging the lie. The projected Glamour and the unfinished House.
³Bulletholes, Dayton aesthetic. While similar, unlike last week’s example of the same lyric, contextually here this line becomes a more hard hitting verse. After painting the picture many Yugoslavs have come to know (of the gravel and the bricks), the artist adds details to the portrait of the bulletholes (Rupe od metaka literally translated is Holes from bullets) and the scars from the shrapnel prosthetics. Here the full picture of the architecture these kids grew up with is complete; one of holes from bullets and marks from shrapnel from a time before, juxtaposed with the current ambition of fresh cement, fresh bricks and fresh mortars on houses potentially new but never finished.
In one instance you are reminded of a violent past and in the other of a hopeful future, and in between the reality; neither seem real. The architecture is a reflection of an almost schizophrenia of national identity. The ambition embedded in every natural organism to overcome is met with the reality of Man’s horrific ideologies imprinted violently for the coming generations to reckon with.
The artist throws all this away, not with a soft song this time, but with a fuck it.
⁴You ask me how it’s going, don’t ask. In Serbo-Bosnian if someone responds with Ne pitaj (Don’t ask) it means Don’t even go there my guy. This could refer to a relationship, to work, to anything at all. Here the artist, after claiming [he doesn’t] like all of this either urges the listener to not even ask how it’s going because no good can come of this, no good can be seen in the holes from bullets, the shrapnel, the dilapidated homes, the projection of glamour. His final thought for us is a short dialogue: You ask me what it’s like? Don’t even go there.
The major difference between this and Danza’s verse last week is that here there is no mention of the Western Capitalist norms; no one is saving for a Maybach, no mention of street violence, the kind popularised by American rap, there is no basketball or cinema reference, no materialistic braggadocio, the only references are ones that Serbians, Croatians, Bosnians who come from similar places would understand. This was no plea to the West, the artist here did not attempt to build any bridges between worlds or to mould himself into the usual rap norms of clever references to pop culture, to street violence and a tinge of the Balkan tragic in an attempt to reach the popular Westernised masses. No, here he was speaking to us, children of villages whose soul, life and architecture was torn by animals who behaved like Gods, who never spent a moment thinking of us, never spent a moment wondering what kind of houses they would be leaving behind, never considered what bullet holes or shrapnel scars would look like, what the expulsion of hundreds of thousands of people from their ancestral homes looked like, and what it might look like if some of those thousands attempted to return (to normalcy), to try and rebuild a life again, a life, not in a desert, not on a blank canvas, but a life in a dilapidated, unrecognisable and heartbreaking environment they once used to call home and now pretend still is. The place which feels so familiar but now is alien.
It is a schizophrenic and sombre existence. The people that have returned are mostly old. The young have nothing back there. The old tell us of how it was. And the young listen. The old argue about whose fault it all was. The young listen, but they know. It certainly wasn’t ours. The old have ruined a good thing. The old will leave earth soon and we will be left with their aesthetics of the Dayton Peace Accords. Now the question remains, How’s it all going to go?
Better no to ask.
--------------------------------------
The analysis of both of these songs and artists is important not because they are children of war but because they are children born after the war. These children have been saddled with the decisions and misgivings of generations that came before them; the hard survival of everyday life, the daily witnessing of buildings with bulletholes and half-finished houses as living monuments of the past and the current normalised capitalistic hyper-ambition. These artists effectively achieved all this in six to eight rhyme schemes, one needs not wonder which side of history they are on : The architecture of genocide is still genocidal, regardless of reason or faith.